Wisconsin · California · National

Dairy farm insurance that protects the herd, the milk, and the operation.

Livestock mortality, milking-parlor and barn property, equipment breakdown with milk spoilage, dairy product liability, manure-runoff pollution, workers' comp, and milk-tanker auto — purpose-built for dairy operations. A-rated carriers. 15-minute quotes.

15-minute quotes2-hour claims responseLicensed all 50 states20+ years insuring industry
Dairy farm at dawn — milking herd in pasture with barn and parlor

240+

Dairy operations insured — herds, parlors, creameries, and family dairies

NPN #8608479

Licensed all 50 states

  • Licensed in all 50 states
  • Founded 2005 — 20+ years
  • Dairy-knowledgeable agents
  • 15-minute quote turnaround
  • 2-hour claims response
  • A.M. Best A+ carrier partners
What we insure

Coverage built specifically for dairy farms.

Standard farm policies undervalue registered stock, exclude milk spoilage, and miss the manure-runoff exposure. We build programs designed for working dairies.

Essential coverage

Dairy Cattle & Livestock Mortality

The coverage that defines a dairy's risk. Insures your milking cows, heifers, calves, and registered breeding stock against death from accident, disease, theft, and disaster — including named peril and full-mortality options on high-value animals.

Explore coverage

Farm Property & Buildings

All-risk coverage for the dairy complex — freestall barns, milking parlors and holding areas, commodity sheds, commodity and bunker silos, feed storage, and the contents and inventory inside them. Built for livestock and manure exposures.

Explore coverage

Equipment Breakdown & Milk Spoilage

Covers mechanical or electrical breakdown of the equipment your operation depends on — milking systems, plate coolers, bulk tanks, compressors and chillers — plus the milk and product spoilage that follows when cooling or processing fails.

Explore coverage

Dairy Product Liability

Coverage for bodily injury or property damage arising from contaminated, mislabeled, or defective milk and dairy products after they leave your farm or creamery — including recall costs and defense when a foodborne-illness or adulteration claim is made.

Explore coverage

General Liability Insurance

Third-party bodily injury and property damage protection for farm visitors, farm tours and agri-tourism, deliveries, custom heifer raising, and the day-to-day operations of running a working dairy.

Explore coverage

Workers' Compensation

Coverage for the real injury patterns in dairy work — animal-handling and trampling injuries, milking-parlor slip and crush injuries, equipment and PTO incidents, and chemical and manure-exposure claims. Proper class codes for dairy labor.

Explore coverage

Commercial Auto & Trucking

Coverage for the milk tankers, feed and commodity trucks, pickup trucks, tractors, and equipment you run on public roads — including hired and non-owned auto when employees use their own vehicles on dairy business.

Explore coverage

Pollution & Environmental Liability

Covers the environmental exposure every dairy carries — manure storage and lagoon failure, nutrient and fertilizer runoff, fuel and chemical leaks, and the cleanup and third-party claims that follow a release into soil or water.

Explore coverage

Not sure what you need? Get a coverage review →

Why dairies switch to us

The coverage gaps that cost dairy farms the most.

Most agents hand a dairy a generic farm-owner policy and call it done. Then a barn fire, a bulk-tank failure, or a manure-runoff claim hits and the exclusion kicks in. We underwrite the parts of your operation everyone else leaves out.

Run by people who know agriculture

Contractors Choice Agency was founded in 2005 by people from the trades and the land. We've walked parlors, valued registered stock, and know what a milking system or bulk tank costs to replace.

Livestock mortality valued like it should be

Standard farm policies pay grade-cattle values for registered stock. We place mortality coverage that reflects the real value of your milking cows and breeding animals.

Equipment breakdown with milk spoilage

Milking systems, bulk tanks, and chillers fail — and a tank of milk spoils with them. We build equipment-breakdown programs that include the spoilage that follows.

Manure-runoff and environmental coverage

Every dairy carries lagoon and nutrient-runoff exposure. Standard policies exclude it. We place environmental liability that covers a release into soil or water.

Farm property built for livestock exposure

Parlors, freestall barns, silos, and feed storage don't fit generic forms — and livestock and manure change the fire and liability profile. We schedule it correctly.

We place the hard dairy risks

Been declined over manure exposure, a barn-fire loss run, or OSHA citations? We have E&S markets for dairies others won't touch.

Run by a former contractor

Josh Cotner knows how operations work and what happens when coverage fails at claim time — on the farm and off.

How it works

From quote request to bound policy in about a day.

No two-week back-and-forth. A real conversation, real markets, and a program you can actually understand — built around your herd and operation.

Step 01

Tell us about your dairy

15-min call or form. Herd size and value, milking system and parlor, equipment and feed, and the coverage lines your old carrier excluded.

Step 02

We shop specialty ag markets

Niche markets that actually write dairy livestock mortality and spoilage — not generic farm markets that carve them out.

Step 03

Bind a program built for dairy

Livestock mortality + property + equipment & spoilage + workers' comp + pollution, coordinated so there are no gaps across your operation.

Step 04

Claims support that moves fast

When a barn fire, bulk-tank failure, or runoff claim arrives, you reach a person with context — not a queue. 2-hour response.

Start my quote

Or call 844-967-5247 — usually answered live.

Where we write

Dairy farm coverage. All 50 states.

From Wisconsin and California to the Northeast creameries and Southwest desert dairies, Contractors Choice Agency writes dairy insurance in every state where dairy operations run.

  • WisconsinAmerica's Dairyland — heritage and modern freestall dairies
  • CaliforniaCentral Valley — the largest dairy state by production
  • Pacific NorthwestOregon, Washington, Idaho — organic and pasture-based herds
  • Northeast & Mid-AtlanticNY, PA, VT, New England — registered stock and creameries
  • Upper MidwestMinnesota, Michigan, Iowa — family tie-stall to parlor operations
  • Texas & the SouthwestTX, NM, AZ — large-herd desert dairies
  • U.S. SoutheastFL, GA, the Carolinas — heat, storm, and high-rainfall exposure
  • Great PlainsKS, NE, the Dakotas — herd, feed, and trucking operations
Licensed & writing in all 50 states — NPN #8608479
Dairy farm landscape with milking herd, barns, and parlor — national dairy coverage

National coverage for dairy operations.

Writing dairy programs in all 50 states since 2005.

0+

Dairy operations insured nationwide

0+

Years insuring farm operations

0 min

Average quote turnaround

0

States licensed & writing

From dairy producers

Dairies that found coverage that actually pays.

When we lost registered Jerseys in a barn fire, our old policy undervalued the herd and shorted us on the building. Dairy Insurance rebuilt the parlor at replacement cost and the livestock mortality actually reflected what those animals were worth. Night and day.

Marlene S.

Herd Owner · Wisconsin

A chiller failed overnight and we lost a full bulk tank. The equipment-breakdown and spoilage coverage paid the milk and the repair fast — no arguing about whether a compressor counts. They get that downtime and spoilage are the real costs on a dairy.

Carl R.

Operations Manager · California

Two carriers had declined us over manure-runoff and lagoon exposure. These folks understood our nutrient-management plan, documented it, and placed an A-rated environmental and property program. Real dairy knowledge, not a generic farm quote.

Diane K.

Co-op Member · New York

Questions, answered

Dairy farm insurance, in plain English.

A working dairy typically needs livestock mortality for the herd, farm property for barns and the milking parlor, equipment breakdown with milk spoilage, dairy product liability, general liability, workers' compensation, commercial auto for milk tankers and feed trucks, and pollution/environmental coverage for manure and runoff. Most dairies carry all eight as one coordinated program.

It depends on herd size and value, parlor and equipment value, payroll and crew size, acreage and feed inventory, and loss history. Small pasture dairies may pay a few thousand a year; large parlor operations with high-value registered stock and significant equipment run considerably more. We quote your actual operation in about 15 minutes — never a generic estimate.

Only if livestock mortality is specifically scheduled. A standard farm-owner policy covers buildings and liability but pays little or nothing for the death of animals. Livestock mortality insurance is what covers the herd against death from disease, accident, disaster, and theft.

Named-peril (limited) mortality pays only for death from specific listed causes — fire, lightning, certain accidents. Full (broad) mortality covers death from almost any cause, including disease. Full mortality costs more but is what most dairies want for valuable milking cows and registered breeding stock.

It can, but only if they're properly scheduled and valued. Many farm policies cap or exclude specialized equipment, or pay actual cash value with heavy depreciation. We schedule parlors, bulk tanks, and chillers at replacement cost so a loss doesn't leave you underinsured.

Not under a standard property policy. Milk and product spoilage from equipment breakdown requires an equipment-breakdown endorsement (often called boiler & machinery) with a spoilage component. Without it, a chiller failure that ruins a full bulk tank is an uncovered loss.

Often yes. If you bottle, process, sell raw milk, direct-market, or produce cheese or other dairy products, product liability covers bodily-illness and recall claims from contaminated or mislabeled product. Even dairies shipping to a co-op can be named in a downstream foodborne-illness claim.

Standard farm and general liability policies exclude pollution. Manure storage, lagoon failure, nutrient and fertilizer runoff, and chemical leaks need dedicated pollution/environmental liability — which we place specifically for dairies.

In most states, yes — workers' comp is required once you have employees, and dairy work is high-hazard. Animal handling, parlor slip and crush injuries, equipment and PTO incidents, and chemical exposure all make proper workers' comp essential. We class-code dairy labor correctly.

Dairy operations carry several codes — milking and herd workers, feeding and field crews, equipment operators, and office staff. Correct classification matters: wrong codes mean overpayment, undercoverage, and audit surprises. We assign codes to your actual workflow.

Vehicles used on public roads — milk tankers, feed and commodity trucks, pickups, and tractors in transit — need commercial auto. Farm auto forms often limit or exclude over-the-road trucking and hired/non-owned use. We coordinate auto with your inland marine and transit coverage.

Only with the right coverage in place. The barn is covered under farm property, but the animals lost are covered under livestock mortality — and only up to their scheduled value. A barn fire is one of the most common ways dairies discover their stock was undervalued.

Agri-tourism, farm tours, petting zoos, and on-farm events add premises-liability exposure that standard farm policies often exclude or under-limit. General liability with an agri-tourism endorsement covers visitor injuries — tell us if you host the public.

Livestock mortality claims are paid against records — animal ID, breed, value, and sometimes vet history. Incomplete records mean delayed or reduced payments. We help you document the herd properly up front so a claim is paid quickly and at full value.

Yes. Registered, show, and high-genetic animals carry values far above grade cattle and must be insured individually on their merit. Standard mortality pays a flat rate; we schedule high-value animals at their real worth.

Yes. Organic dairies carry the premium value of certified stock and feed, and pasture-based and seasonal dairies have different equipment, labor, and feed profiles. We tailor the program — including organic feed and certified-stock values — to how you actually farm.

Yes. Contractors Choice Agency is licensed in all 50 states and has markets for dairy operations whether your farm is in Wisconsin, California, the Northeast, or anywhere in between.

Typically 15 minutes on a call. For larger programs with high-value stock or significant equipment we may need a day or two to involve the right markets, but we move fast and tell you the timeline up front.

Often yes. We have admitted and excess-and-surplus (E&S) markets for dairies declined over manure exposure, a prior barn-fire or mortality loss run, OSHA citations, or other issues. Bring us what you have and we'll find a path.

Usually yes. Bundling livestock mortality, property, equipment & spoilage, workers' comp, pollution, and auto into one coordinated program closes gaps between policies and is almost always cheaper and cleaner than separate policies from separate carriers.

15-minute quotes · 2-hour claims response

Protect Your Dairy Operation with coverage built for the herd.

Whether you need livestock mortality today or a full program — property, equipment and spoilage, workers' comp, pollution, and auto — one call gets you real quotes from specialty ag markets. Not a voicemail and a two-week wait.

No obligation. No spam. Licensed all 50 states.